Magic Bagels in Valley Stream

Quality of bagels has dropped of considerably since business was sold. Bagels taste like those you could buy in California.

Homey, brings me back to childhood, good bagels.

Picked up Raw, completely uncooked, sticky doughy bagels Saturday morning 🙄 magic bagels has gone downhill.

New owners and new renovations with the same amazing bagels that they’re so well known for. The store seems much more open and larger which makes it feel like a nicer place to plop down and get some homework done. I highly recommend taking a peek and grabbing something to eat while you’re at it !

First time here bagels are fresh and delicious can't complain. Stop by and get a fresh bagel !

I love the new look and thank god the bagels remain the same as they have always been...delicious!!!

Excellent bagel, down to earth vibes.

USED TO BE GOOD AND A WARM FAMILY FEELING WHEN YOU WENT INNOT ANYMORE!!!If you want bagels go somewhere else. ISSUES LISTED BELOW:1. NEW OWNERS ABILITY TO BE FRIENDLY AND INTERFACE WITH CUSTOMERS 0 0UT OF 10.2. BAGELS ARE NOW DOUGHY, MORE LIKE ROLLS. THIS IS FROM THE NEW OWNERS TRYING TO MAKE THEM CHEAPER!!! (RUINING THE PRODUCT)3. PRICES. OMG. BAGEL WITH CHICKEN SALAD 5.00. I CAN GO NEXT DOOR AND GET A BACON EGG AND CHEESE CHEAPER.YAH KNOW WHAT. JUST GO NEXT DOOR INSTEAD.4. STAFF. HAH. DON'T GIVE A DAMN. BUT YOU CAN TELL THIS IS FROM THE NEW OWNERS WAY THEY TREAT THEIR STAFF!!!THE GUY STEVE IS THE ONLY WITH PERSONALITY AND PROPER CUSTOMER ATTITUDE.5. ADVICE TO NEW OWNERS. LEARN YOUR CUSTOMERS AND PRODUCT. LEARN TO INTERFACE BETTER AND LOSE THE RESTING I HATE PEOPLE FACE.

The staff is amazing, fast and friendly! The food is simply delicious! This is the perfect place to start off a great morning! I highly recommend to ALL! :)

I came back to magic bagels after a long time and saw they had new management. I will not be coming back. The staff is so unprofessional. The girl that was serving me rushed my order to go back and gossip with someone. The person also was talking to her coworker about personal life while making my order. Very unorganized and unprofessional. Very sad because ive been coming here since i was in high school. Miss the old staff!!

Great bagel place. Staff always friendly too.

Staff is always pleasent and the bagels are always freshly baked and amazing While their bagels are a good size they are not do big that you end up over eating like some other bagel places. They are always busy because they are so popular. One of my favorite places to go to. Oh by the way their coffee is wonderful. They freshly grind the beans before brewing.

I come here every day and they always deliver the same great treatment to customers and the environment is nice to relax in.

I've been coming to this place over 20 years.Loved my bagels and coffee every morning but things have changed.One of the guys who actually makes the bagels smokes cigarettes outside of the establishment is that even sanitary to smoke then make bagels?Then there is this older lady who serves she arrives late comes in without washing her hands grabs a bagel barehanded and Snapple to take outside to someone ....none of my business right I then have the privilege of her serving me while wiping the cold from her eyes and she sees no problem with it I was disgusted and I'll probably never go there again.Service is nowhere how it use to be

Best bagel in valley stream, nice fresh and soft , very friendly

Best bagels on Long Island 👌🏻!

It was a warm and friendly place not anymore.I was waiting patiently to place a order but was totally ignored.So I walked out

Great place, Friendly Staff nice area

Great bagels

Nice service . Calm environment . But bagels were not fresh and hard for no reason . Lox tasted Ok-ish. .Not a bad place and the only think I tried was lox and cream cheese .

Magic makes the best bagels in townAlways fresh and has great flavored cream cheese.The staff Maria, to my, & the rest of the staff are friendly and experienced

Magic bagel has throughout the years provided fresh ingredients and great products. It was family owned and operated at one point in time. However it appears to have changed ownership. I love the new look. Time will tell if they keep the standards and quality valley steam have enjoyed and appreciated throughout the years.

Great food an SERVICE

Great place delicious bagels and great salads

$10 minimum on credit cards. No egg sandwiches.

Magic bagels is a self serve bagel shop. The bagels are really good. They are fluffy and thick. There is a huge variety. I like the everything whole wheat bagels, with either vegetable cream cheese or cinnamon raisin cream cheese. The bagel shops serves a good portion of cream cheese on the bagel. The coffee is delicious. The staff is very friendly and helpful. The price is reasonable. There is plenty of complimentary parking.

Coming from queens where the bagel are top notch, Magic bagels has good quality bagels. The customer service is good, you never wait too long.

Good bagels, but they don't have hot breakfast/ sandwiches

Amazing bagel spot! They have a large variety of cream cheese selection and bagels. They have the thinner side of bagels as well, perfection. The 2 ladies working were very helpful, patient, nice and welcoming. I'm sure to be back and recommend to friends and family.

They don't serve "sandwich" bagels and there is a $10 minimum. I just wanted a simple bagel but didn't have cash so I couldn't purchase my order. Never coming back here.

Delicious bagels.

good food, reasonable prices, fast and friendly service

Magic bagels have new owners.I have been in magic bagels 3 times since the new owners ,each time 3 different prices for a bagel and cream cheese. They are very unorganized. I wish them the best of luck,count me out.They need to get it together the original bagel shop was excellent!!!

Best bagels ever in valley Stream!!! They are so fresh......

I was staying nearby from out of town and stopped in my first day for breakfast. The aroma of fresh bagels wafted outside when I walked by and I couldn't resist. Well, they didn't disappoint that first visit, and I was in town for the next 8 days and went there every day for breakfast or lunch. Sue and the entire staff are very friendly and accommodating. Orders are quickly filled, and prices are very reasonable. I should have tried their home made soup and pastries, but I was so hooked on the bagels I didn't have room for the rest. This is my #1 place for bagels in NY. I hope to come back soon and often.

Bagels are small but good. They don't make eggs in the morning.

The bagels ste deicious. I had one today .my wife took the wrong medine and made a fool of herself and I think she got fired

New owners same great bagel's

Complete make over very nice, clean, good coffee and bagels along with good staff service.

Magic Bagels Is One Of My Favorite Bagel Shops To Eat At!!! They Have Excellent Bagels and Service Here!! They Get Five Stars Also!!!!!!

Great service more for money I will highly recommended Keep the good work up guys great job.

Very clean and always have your order ready! Wonderful friendly staff

The chicken salad is sooooo good!

I had 150 Bagels transported from Magic Bagel to Central Florida. A relative was visiting Long Island and I was craving a good old New York Bagel. Mike & Michelle from Magic Bagels came through with a great assortment. Everything was perfect the bagels are delicious the secret is store them in separate ziplock bags freeze them immediately and every time you want a fresh bagel take it right from the freezer into the toaster oven just under 10 minutes at 350 degrees it's as fresh as you just bought it. Thank you Mike and Michelle next time I'm in town I plan on visiting and picking up another order. Well done guys........ craving satisfied for now.

Ever since the management changed the quality has gone down! I'm so upset! Too stingy with the cream cheese!

Delicious bagels. Fast service. My daughter's favorite here is their Rainbow Bagel!

A staple of the town. My grandparents brought my mother here and then myself. Since they moved away we always bring some to family events as a surprise. Delicious bagels and spreads

The service is quick, the food isnt overpriced and the location is convenient.

Very good fresh bagels, plus variety of other breakfast items. Prices is good and Staff is friendly!!

All time favorite bagel shop. Still makes me wonder how such a good bagel costs so little! Bring cash, they don't take card and avoid going when the kids from the high school are on lunch or you will be waiting on line forever! Definitely worth a try, it's my absolute favorite!